Let’s be honest: Joe Tate in Emmerdale should be iconic. Instead, he is exhausting.
Schemes, vendettas, blackmail, threats. Rinse and repeat. What once felt sharp and dangerous now feels tired. Emmerdale is in real danger of turning one of its biggest legacy names into a pantomime villain with no depth.
The clock is ticking. Either redeem him properly or go all in on the darkness. Right now he is stuck in a dull middle ground.
Joe Tate’s return to Emmerdale promised fireworks but fizzled out
When it was revealed on Christmas Eve 2024 that Joe Tate was heading back to the village, fans were thrilled. A Tate return should mean power plays, family warfare and proper drama.
Instead, the direction has felt confused.
First, Joe teamed up with the late Will Taylor to take Kim down. Then Will died and suddenly that plan vanished. Joe and Kim pivoted into bonding mode and the vendetta was quietly shelved. It made the whole arc feel pointless.
Next came the kidney storyline. Rather than simply ask for help, Joe spiralled into deception, drugging Noah, triggering the lake limo crash and setting off a chain of events that led to Leyla, Amy and Suzy losing their lives. He then stabbed Caleb to secure the transplant.
All the while viewers were left wondering why he did not just ask.
Then there was the grand love affair with Dawn Fletcher. Meant to be passionate and sweeping, it has struggled to convince. The chemistry simply has not matched the scale the story demanded.
More lies, more blackmail, more revenge
Now we are watching Joe manipulate and intimidate his way towards control of Moira’s farm.
He played a part in sending her to prison. He blackmailed Victoria and Robert over John’s death to secure their share of Butler’s. Now he continues to circle the Dingle and Barton families at their most vulnerable.
When his flashy DeLorean was stolen, he immediately set his sights on revenge against Cain. His chilling declaration that ruining Cain’s life is now priority number one was meant to feel menacing.
Instead, it felt predictable.
How many times can we watch Joe threaten to destroy someone before it loses impact?
Even Graham’s loyalty feels murky
Next week, Graham heads to Cain’s to retrieve the stolen car keys but stops in his tracks when he spots Cain’s oncology letter.
Suddenly, Graham is protecting him. He lies to Joe, claiming joyriders took the car. Later, he urges Cain to focus on his cancer treatment and supporting Moira rather than fighting the Tates.
It is an interesting shift. But it also highlights the issue. Joe now feels detached from the emotional core of the show, while other characters are developing layers and unlikely alliances.
So how does Emmerdale fix Joe Tate?
Right now, Joe feels one note. Constantly scheming. Constantly manipulating. And facing very little consequence.
He was pushed out of a window by Dawn and recovered in record time. He has not truly paid for the deaths linked to the crash. There has been no lasting fallout for stealing Caleb’s kidney. The blackmail and intimidation continue unchecked.
At Christmas, there were glimpses of something more interesting. Joe talking about wanting to be more like his mother, Rachel Hughes, rather than his ruthless father Chris. His softer scenes with Sam and the Dingles hinted at complexity.
That is the Joe worth investing in.
If redemption is the goal, then commit to it. Strip away the endless plotting. Force him to confront what he has done. Let him lose properly. Maybe even send him to prison and rebuild him from there.
If not, then lean fully into villain territory. Expose him as the ultimate puppet master. Give him a dramatic end game worthy of the Tate name.
What cannot continue is this repetitive cycle of threats without payoff.
Emmerdale has a choice to make. Either give Joe depth or give him consequences. Because right now, viewers are running out of patience.
Read more: Emmerdale cast shake-up 2026 as exits confirmed and big returns teased – so who’s leaving?
Emmerdale usually airs weeknights on ITV at 8pm, with an early release on ITVX at 7am.
Leave us a comment on our Facebook page @EntertainmentDailyFix and let us know what you think!